Clean Water Rule's Repeal Could Have Consequences for Sprawling Development in Arizona

A recent decision by the Trump administration regarding the Waters of the United States Rule is changing the legal calculus of a plan to add 28,000 homes in the city of Benson, located southwest of Tucson.

2 minute read

September 24, 2019, 11:00 AM PDT

By James Brasuell @CasualBrasuell


The San Pedro River where it passes through Saint David, south of Benson, Arizona.

The San Pedro River where it passes through Saint David, south of Benson, Arizona. | Tim Roberts Photography / Shutterstock

The Trump administration's actions to repeal the Waters of the United States Rule have the developer a massive master planned community outside of Tucson talking optimistically about the prospects for the development in court.

As noted by Planetizen in a post earlier this month, the developer El Dorado Holdings is planning a development called Vigneto in the city of Benson, just east of Tucson in Arizona. The project would add 28,000 homes to the city.

After the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers reissued a Clean Water Act permit for the project, six environmental groups—the Lower San Pedro Watershed Alliance, Center for Biological Diversity, Sierra Club, Maricopa Audubon Society, Tucson Audubon Society, and Cascabel Conservation Association—filed legal challenges to the project.

But the Trump administration's decision earlier this month to roll back clean water protections under the Waters of the United States Rule, approved during the Obama administration, is likely to have consequences for the legal case, according to an article by Ian James.

Developer Mike Reinbold believes the development will move ahead soon as a result of the actions by the Trump administration. "Once the new regulation takes effect, perhaps as early as January, Reinbold said the federal permit for dredge-and-fill construction work on 51 acres of the property will no longer be required," reports James. If Reinbold's theory plays out in court, construction could begin as early as next year.

"Opponents of the project disagree with the developers’ interpretation of the law, and say they plan to keep fighting the development, which they say would harm the San Pedro River," according to James.

James cites more interest groups to further elaborate on the issues under debate, including the effectiveness of conservation laws.

Monday, September 23, 2019 in Arizona Republic

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Close-up of park ranger in green jacket and khaki hat looking out at Bryce Canyon National Park red rock formations.

National Parks Layoffs Will Cause Communities to Lose Billions

Thousands of essential park workers were laid off this week, just before the busy spring break season.

February 18, 2025 - National Parks Traveler

Paved walking path next to canal in The Woodlands, Texas with office buildings in background.

Retro-silient?: America’s First “Eco-burb,” The Woodlands Turns 50

A master-planned community north of Houston offers lessons on green infrastructure and resilient design, but falls short of its founder’s lofty affordability and walkability goals.

February 19, 2025 - Greg Flisram

Small rural USPS post office in manufactured one-story grey building with American flag in front.

Delivering for America Plan Will Downgrade Mail Service in at Least 49.5 Percent of Zip Codes

Republican and Democrat lawmakers criticize the plan for its disproportionate negative impact on rural communities.

February 12, 2025 - Cowboy State Daily

Chicago

Test News Post 1

This is a summary

April 8 - 2TheAdvocate.com

test alt text

Test News Headline 46

Test for the image on the front page.

March 5 - Cleantech blog

Military humvee driving through gate at Fort Indiantown Gap Natl Guard training center in Pennsylvania surrounded by winter trees and dead leaves.

Balancing Bombs and Butterflies: How the National Guard Protects a Rare Species

The National Guard at Fort Indiantown Gap uses GIS technology and land management strategies to balance military training with conservation efforts, ensuring the survival of the rare eastern regal fritillary butterfly.

February 24 - Esri Blog