Don't Separate Planning From Architecture

A separate competition to design a memorial at Ground Zero is not required, argues architecture critic Herbert Muschamp. We've got 'memorial fatigue' he says, and it's all Maya Lin's fault.

1 minute read

December 23, 2002, 7:00 AM PST

By Abhijeet Chavan @http://twitter.com/legalaidtech


"The design process got off on the wrong foot when the development corporation tried to separate planning from architecture, thereby relegating the latter discipline to the status of an afterthought...In theory, the designs do not include specific plans for a memorial to those who died when the Twin Towers were destroyed. A separate competition has been scheduled for that part of the redevelopment project. But how could you reasonably expect architects to keep their minds off the project's architectural heart?...All cities are memorials. Civilization is mostly a history of rebuilding them after catastrophes, not planning them from scratch... Many people are naturally offended by the perception of ground zero as a potential site for great contemporary architecture. Wouldn't that be tantamount to dancing on a mass grave?...The whole thing is the memorial: the designs; the debates they provoke; the self-awareness that emerges in the course of the debate; and the shifting shape of the city in the light of that awareness."

Thanks to The Practice of New Urbanism

Sunday, December 22, 2002 in The New York Times

portrait of professional woman

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching. Mary G., Urban Planner

I love the variety of courses, many practical, and all richly illustrated. They have inspired many ideas that I've applied in practice, and in my own teaching.

Mary G., Urban Planner

Get top-rated, practical training

Red 1972 Ford Pinto with black racing stripes on display with man sitting in driver's seat.

Analysis: Cybertruck Fatality Rate Far Exceeds That of Ford Pinto

The Tesla Cybertruck was recalled seven times last year.

July 2, 2025 - Mother Jones

Close-up of park ranger in green jacket and khaki hat looking out at Bryce Canyon National Park red rock formations.

National Parks Layoffs Will Cause Communities to Lose Billions

Thousands of essential park workers were laid off this week, just before the busy spring break season.

February 18, 2025 - National Parks Traveler

Paved walking path next to canal in The Woodlands, Texas with office buildings in background.

Retro-silient?: America’s First “Eco-burb,” The Woodlands Turns 50

A master-planned community north of Houston offers lessons on green infrastructure and resilient design, but falls short of its founder’s lofty affordability and walkability goals.

February 19, 2025 - Greg Flisram

Screenshot of shade map of Buffalo, New York with legend.

Test News Post 1

This is a summary

0 seconds ago - 2TheAdvocate.com

Red 1972 Ford Pinto with black racing stripes on display with man sitting in driver's seat.

Analysis: Cybertruck Fatality Rate Far Exceeds That of Ford Pinto

The Tesla Cybertruck was recalled seven times last year.

18 minutes ago - Mother Jones

test alt text

Test News Headline 46

Test for the image on the front page.

March 5 - Cleantech blog